sadalawpublications.com

A DYNAMIC LAW JOURNAL

Menu

Live cases

Supreme Court Questions Centre on Algorithmic Policing and AI Bias: A Step Toward Digital Rights Reform

Leave a Comment / Live cases /

Trending Today Supreme Court Questions Centre on Algorithmic Policing and AI Bias: A Step Toward Digital Rights Reform LEGAL INTERNSHIP OPPORTUNITY AT BOBBLE AI INTERNSHIP OPPORTUNITY AT SETTLEMENTOFLOAN LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT BP, PUNE LEGAL INTERNSHIP OPPORTUNITY AT HYPERVERGE, BENGALURU LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT INSOLVENCY AND BANKRUPTCY BOARD OF INDIA Delhi High Court Orders Status Report on Legal Aid Shortage — Justice Must Not Be Costly Supreme Court Pulls Up Centre and States Over Faulty Public Health Infrastructure — A Wake-Up Call for Healthcare Accountability Supreme Court Seeks Update on National DNA Data Bank Compliance — A Turning Point for Forensic Justice LEGAL INTERNSHIP OPPORTUNITY AT ABHINAV BHATIA & ASSOCIATES Supreme Court Questions Centre on Algorithmic Policing and AI Bias: A Step Toward Digital Rights Reform Kashish Jahan 30 JULY 2025 The Supreme Court of India has asked the Centre to clarify its strategy on algorithmic policing, facial recognition, and AI-based surveillance, citing concerns over privacy, constitutional rights, and lack of oversight in law enforcement. Supreme Court Flags Dangers of Unregulated AI Surveillance On 26 July 2025, the Supreme Court of India agreed to hear a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) seeking regulation of AI-driven law enforcement tools. These include predictive policing algorithms, facial recognition systems, and other crime-mapping software used by police departments. A Bench led by Justice Kavya Nair emphasized that such technologies—if left unchecked—could undermine fundamental rights under Article 21 (Right to Life and Personal Liberty) and Article 14 (Right to Equality). Facial Recognition and the Risk to Privacy The petition brings attention to instances where facial recognition technology misidentified individuals in public areas, resulting in wrongful suspicion or arrest. These errors expose citizens to serious consequences without transparency, oversight, or legal redress, especially when algorithms operate in secrecy. “No Due Process for AI,” Says Justice Nair Justice Kavya Nair remarked that algorithmic systems are becoming de facto law enforcement tools, but there is currently no legal framework to guide their use. The Court emphasized the importance of: Implementing bias audits to detect and prevent algorithmic discrimination Maintaining human oversight in automated decision-making Preserving constitutional safeguards at all stages of AI deployment Centre and States Asked to Respond The Court has issued notices to the Ministry of Home Affairs, the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology, and several State Police Departments. They have been asked to submit responses within four weeks detailing: Existing policies for AI use in policing Data protection protocols Mechanisms for public accountability and oversight A Step Toward Ethical AI in Law Enforcement This PIL could set the stage for a national framework on the ethical use of artificial intelligence in criminal justice. If the Court insists on enforceable safeguards, India may become a global leader in balancing public safety with digital rights, privacy, and individual dignity in a modern democracy. Conclusion: The Need for AI Regulation in Policing As AI tools continue to influence policing in India, clear guidelines and legal standards are essential. Without them, technology risks replacing justice with automation. The Court’s proactive stance could ensure that innovation does not come at the cost of civil liberties. Leave a Reply Cancel Reply Logged in as Sadalaw. Edit your profile. Log out? Required fields are marked * Message* Live Cases Supreme Court Questions Centre on Algorithmic Policing and AI Bias: A Step Toward Digital Rights Reform Sadalaw • July 30, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments Delhi High Court Orders Status Report on Legal Aid Shortage — Justice Must Not Be Costly Sadalaw • July 29, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments Supreme Court Pulls Up Centre and States Over Faulty Public Health Infrastructure — A Wake-Up Call for Healthcare Accountability Sadalaw • July 29, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments 1 2 3 … 5 Next »

Supreme Court Questions Centre on Algorithmic Policing and AI Bias: A Step Toward Digital Rights Reform Read More »

Delhi High Court Orders Status Report on Legal Aid Shortage — Justice Must Not Be Costly

Leave a Comment / Live cases /

Trending Today Delhi High Court Orders Status Report on Legal Aid Shortage — Justice Must Not Be Costly Supreme Court Pulls Up Centre and States Over Faulty Public Health Infrastructure — A Wake-Up Call for Healthcare Accountability Supreme Court Seeks Update on National DNA Data Bank Compliance — A Turning Point for Forensic Justice LEGAL INTERNSHIP OPPORTUNITY AT ABHINAV BHATIA & ASSOCIATES LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT NATIONAL INSURANCE ACADEMY LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT NATIONAL COOPERATIVE DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT PODDAR BRIO COLLEGE OF LAW, THANE LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT CHAMBERS OF DEVASHISH CHAUHAN LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT PEOPLE FOR ANIMALS (PFA), NEW DELHI LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT OUTLAWED INDIA, BANGALORE Delhi High Court Orders Status Report on Legal Aid Shortage — Justice Must Not Be Costly Kashish Jahan 29 JULY 2025 The Delhi High Court has asked the Legal Services Authority to explain the alarming shortage of legal aid lawyers in the capital. This move could bring long-overdue reforms to ensure free legal representation for all. Millions Still Locked Out of Legal Help On 26 July 2025, the Delhi High Court directed the Delhi State Legal Services Authority (DSLSA) and the Government of Delhi to submit an affidavit detailing the shortage of legal aid lawyers in the city’s courts. A bench led by Justice Neha Kapoor observed that free legal aid is a constitutional right under Article 39A of the Indian Constitution, yet thousands of individuals—especially from marginalised communities—remain unrepresented due to bureaucratic delays and mismanagement. Legal Aid Platforms Largely Underutilised The case arose from a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) filed by a civic rights NGO, which submitted data showing that only 22% of eligible individuals in Delhi received legal representation over the past year. Key findings presented in the PIL included: Multiple district courts had no active legal aid panel Appointed legal aid lawyers were often absent during hearings Victims of custodial violence and undertrial prisoners were left without representation Court Criticises Institutional Complacency Justice Kapoor noted that “delayed or denied legal aid is the ultimate denial of justice.” She asserted that the right to legal representation cannot be viewed as a charitable service, but must be part of a systematic and enforceable framework. The court also warned against inconsistent implementation, stating that legal aid should not be a privilege based on geography or discretion. Directions to Restore Access to Legal Aid To address these systemic failures, the Court issued the following directives. The Delhi Legal Services Authority must submit a status report within 10 days, including: 1. Unassisted Applicant Statistics Number of eligible applicants who went unrepresented in each court 2. Reasons for Lawyer Shortages Gaps in panel rosters, recruitment delays, and resource issues 3. Improvement Roadmap Plans to: Recruit more panel lawyers Launch mobile legal clinics Implement 24×7 legal helplines Justice Beyond Affordability Legal experts argue that this order has the potential to redefine access to justice in Delhi. If fully implemented, the ruling could ensure: Legal aid in every police station and tribunal Real-time access to lawyers for underprivileged and vulnerable citizens Fulfilment of constitutional guarantees beyond paper compliance By prioritising structure and accountability, the court aims to transform legal aid from a formality into a functional lifeline. Leave a Reply Cancel Reply Logged in as Sadalaw. Edit your profile. Log out? Required fields are marked * Message* Live Cases Delhi High Court Orders Status Report on Legal Aid Shortage — Justice Must Not Be Costly Sadalaw • July 29, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments Supreme Court Pulls Up Centre and States Over Faulty Public Health Infrastructure — A Wake-Up Call for Healthcare Accountability Sadalaw • July 29, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments Supreme Court Seeks Update on National DNA Data Bank Compliance — A Turning Point for Forensic Justice Sadalaw • July 29, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments 1 2 3 … 5 Next »

Delhi High Court Orders Status Report on Legal Aid Shortage — Justice Must Not Be Costly Read More »

Supreme Court Pulls Up Centre and States Over Faulty Public Health Infrastructure — A Wake-Up Call for Healthcare Accountability

Leave a Comment / Live cases /

Trending Today Supreme Court Pulls Up Centre and States Over Faulty Public Health Infrastructure — A Wake-Up Call for Healthcare Accountability Supreme Court Seeks Update on National DNA Data Bank Compliance — A Turning Point for Forensic Justice LEGAL INTERNSHIP OPPORTUNITY AT ABHINAV BHATIA & ASSOCIATES LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT NATIONAL INSURANCE ACADEMY LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT NATIONAL COOPERATIVE DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT PODDAR BRIO COLLEGE OF LAW, THANE LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT CHAMBERS OF DEVASHISH CHAUHAN LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT PEOPLE FOR ANIMALS (PFA), NEW DELHI LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT OUTLAWED INDIA, BANGALORE LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT BENETTON Supreme Court Pulls Up Centre and States Over Faulty Public Health Infrastructure — A Wake-Up Call for Healthcare Accountability Kashish Jahan 29 JULY 2025 The Supreme Court has slammed the Centre and States for failing to fix India’s crumbling rural healthcare system. With sharp deadlines and accountability demands, the judiciary may force long-overdue public health reforms. Healthcare Infrastructure Under Judicial Scrutiny On 26 July 2025, the Supreme Court of India voiced strong concern over the deteriorating state of rural healthcare infrastructure in the country. The focus was primarily on the failing conditions of Primary Health Centres (PHCs) and Community Health Centres (CHCs). A bench led by Justice R.K. Sharma declared that the right to health under Article 21 of the Indian Constitution is meaningless if the infrastructure remains underfunded, understaffed, and overlooked by authorities. Data Speaks Louder Than Promises This judicial intervention stems from a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) filed by several health rights groups. The petition cited shocking statistics: Over 40% of PHCs lack specialists or have non-functional operation theatres Numerous CHCs are missing essential medicines and diagnostic tools Despite National Health Mission (NHM) mandates and repeated court directions, compliance remains weak, especially in tribal and hilly districts Court Calls Out Systemic Failures Justice Sharma firmly reminded both State and Central governments that ailing communities cannot afford bureaucratic delays or endless policy reviews. He criticised the constant justification of funding delays and staff shortages as unacceptable. Importantly, the Bench made it clear that inadequate healthcare in state-run facilities, including prisons and protective homes, cannot be excused under the pretext of administrative constraints. Sharpened Orders for Action To restore accountability, the Court directed all States and the Union Ministry of Health and Family Welfare to submit a comprehensive report within three weeks, including: 1. District-Wise Infrastructure Status Number and condition of PHCs and CHCs Vacant medical posts Availability of medical equipment and facilities 2. Budget Utilisation Data Expenditure reports for the last three years Details on fund allocation and actual disbursal 3. Corrective Action Plans Specific timelines for upgrades Appointed accountability officers for every region Toward Constitutional Healthcare According to legal and healthcare experts, India’s public health obligations stem from both its constitutional guarantees and international human rights treaties, such as the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR), which recognises health as a fundamental human right. This Supreme Court hearing could become a policy-shifting moment—forcing states and central agencies to move from promises to action, especially in long-neglected rural and tribal regions. Leave a Reply Cancel Reply Logged in as Sadalaw. Edit your profile. Log out? Required fields are marked * Message* Live Cases Supreme Court Pulls Up Centre and States Over Faulty Public Health Infrastructure — A Wake-Up Call for Healthcare Accountability Sadalaw • July 29, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments Supreme Court Seeks Update on National DNA Data Bank Compliance — A Turning Point for Forensic Justice Sadalaw • July 29, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments Supreme Court Slams Rajasthan Pollution Control Board Over Severe Staffing Shortage Sadalaw • July 19, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments 1 2 3 … 5 Next »

Supreme Court Pulls Up Centre and States Over Faulty Public Health Infrastructure — A Wake-Up Call for Healthcare Accountability Read More »

Supreme Court Seeks Update on National DNA Data Bank Compliance — A Turning Point for Forensic Justice

Leave a Comment / Live cases /

Trending Today Supreme Court Seeks Update on National DNA Data Bank Compliance — A Turning Point for Forensic Justice LEGAL INTERNSHIP OPPORTUNITY AT ABHINAV BHATIA & ASSOCIATES LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT NATIONAL INSURANCE ACADEMY LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT NATIONAL COOPERATIVE DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT PODDAR BRIO COLLEGE OF LAW, THANE LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT CHAMBERS OF DEVASHISH CHAUHAN LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT PEOPLE FOR ANIMALS (PFA), NEW DELHI LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT OUTLAWED INDIA, BANGALORE LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT BENETTON LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT LEVARI Supreme Court Seeks Update on National DNA Data Bank Compliance — A Turning Point for Forensic Justice Kashish Jahan 29 JULY 2025 The Supreme Court has asked the Union Home Ministry for a progress report on implementing the National DNA Data Bank under the 2019 DNA Technology Act. This move could revolutionize forensic justice in India. A Silent Frontier in India’s Criminal Justice Reform On 26 July 2025, the Supreme Court of India directed the Union Ministry of Home Affairs and the Forensic Science Laboratory to provide a detailed status report on the implementation of the National DNA Data Bank, as mandated under the DNA Technology (Use and Application) Regulation Act, 2019. A bench led by Justice S.S. Menon underscored the urgent need to decentralize DNA evidence usage. He stressed that forensic support should not be confined to major metropolitan cities but must serve all states and regions. A System Cumbersome in Practice The Public Interest Litigation (PIL) filed before the Court pointed out serious gaps: Most states lack NABL-accredited forensic laboratories. There is a severe shortage of trained personnel to handle DNA sample collection and analysis. Inadequate funding and infrastructure have delayed justice in numerous criminal cases. As a result, many lower courts face backlogs due to the unavailability of timely and credible forensic reports—leading to delayed verdicts and compromised investigations. Bench Demands Accountability and Urgency Justice Menon observed that without a functioning national DNA database, the DNA law remains ineffective. He warned that poor or delayed forensic analysis could undermine the constitutional right to a fair trial under Article 21 of the Indian Constitution. Strict Reporting Timeline for the Government The Bench has given the Union Home Ministry a strict deadline of four weeks to submit a comprehensive status report covering: 1. State-Wise Lab Assessment Operational status of DNA labs Availability of qualified forensic personnel 2. Accreditation Timeline Timeline for accrediting labs in unserved or under-served states 3. Budget Utilisation Report Detailed expenditure report on the funds disbursed under the 2019 Act Status of fund allocation and usage by state governments Towards a Forensic-First Criminal Justice System Legal and forensic experts believe this directive from the apex court could revolutionize criminal case investigation in India. A well-functioning DNA data system is expected to: Increase conviction accuracy Reduce trial pendency Ensure equal access to forensic justice across the country As Justice Menon stated, “Science, not delay, should be the rule of law.” Leave a Reply Cancel Reply Logged in as Sadalaw. Edit your profile. Log out? Required fields are marked * Message* Live Cases Supreme Court Seeks Update on National DNA Data Bank Compliance — A Turning Point for Forensic Justice Sadalaw • July 29, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments Supreme Court Slams Rajasthan Pollution Control Board Over Severe Staffing Shortage Sadalaw • July 19, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments Supreme Court Backs Himachal Pradesh’s Claim to Higher Hydropower Royalties Sadalaw • July 19, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments 1 2 3 … 5 Next »

Supreme Court Seeks Update on National DNA Data Bank Compliance — A Turning Point for Forensic Justice Read More »

Supreme Court Slams Rajasthan Pollution Control Board Over Severe Staffing Shortage

Leave a Comment / Live cases /

Trending Today Supreme Court Slams Rajasthan Pollution Control Board Over Severe Staffing Shortage Supreme Court Backs Himachal Pradesh’s Claim to Higher Hydropower Royalties Haryana Moves Supreme Court to Shield Aravalli Hills from Cross-Border Mining LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT AMAZON WEB SERVICES, GURUGRAM LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT ADV MOKSH JAIN, MUMBAI LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT CIPLA, MUMBAI LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT ELEVATE JOB OPPORTUNITY AT ANB LEGAL LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT NAKS LEGAL LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT JP LAW ASSOCIATES Supreme Court Slams Rajasthan Pollution Control Board Over Severe Staffing Shortage Kashish Jahan 19 JULY 2025 The Supreme Court has criticized the Rajasthan Pollution Control Board for operating at just 35% staffing capacity. Learn why this judicial warning could trigger urgent reforms in India’s environmental enforcement system. Supreme Court Issues Stern Warning to Rajasthan Government In a sharp rebuke, the Supreme Court of India has reprimanded the Rajasthan government for failing to adequately staff the Rajasthan State Pollution Control Board. The court has warned of contempt proceedings if immediate corrective steps are not taken to address the staffing crisis. Staffing Crisis: Just 35% Operational Capacity The Pollution Control Board is currently operating at only 35% capacity, with numerous critical posts remaining vacant. A major reason behind the shortfall is the rigid promotion policy, which mandates at least five years of experience for engineers to be eligible for advancement. However, the majority of junior engineers have only 2–3 years of experience, effectively blocking upward mobility and contributing to the manpower vacuum. Consequences of Inadequate Staffing Environmental experts warn that this staffing gap is seriously weakening the state’s ability to: Conduct pollution monitoring Perform industrial inspections Enforce environmental regulations This leaves key urban and industrial hubs such as Jaipur, Udaipur, and Kota vulnerable to rising levels of air, water, and industrial pollution. Stopgap Measures Under Scrutiny In an attempt to manage the crisis, the Board temporarily hired 40 interns. However, the Supreme Court strongly objected, stating that: “Interns cannot replace trained officers with statutory enforcement powers.” The court emphasized that such interim fixes do not meet the legal and operational requirements expected from a regulatory body. Court’s Directive: Rethink Policy, Recruit Staff The bench has directed the state government to: Revise its promotion policy Submit a clear timeline for new recruitments Provide a roadmap for sustainable staffing reforms The matter is set to be reviewed again during the next hearing on July 18, 2025, where the state must demonstrate concrete action. A Wake-Up Call for Environmental Governance Nationwide This case serves as a stark reminder that environmental legislation is only effective if backed by functional regulatory bodies. Without adequate staffing, agencies like the Pollution Control Board risk becoming symbolic rather than effective. It also signals to other states that judicial scrutiny will not tolerate administrative inertia in matters of public health and environmental safety. Leave a Reply Cancel Reply Logged in as Sadalaw. Edit your profile. Log out? Required fields are marked * Message* Live Cases Supreme Court Slams Rajasthan Pollution Control Board Over Severe Staffing Shortage Sadalaw • July 19, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments Supreme Court Backs Himachal Pradesh’s Claim to Higher Hydropower Royalties Sadalaw • July 19, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments Haryana Moves Supreme Court to Shield Aravalli Hills from Cross-Border Mining Sadalaw • July 19, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments 1 2 3 … 5 Next »

Supreme Court Slams Rajasthan Pollution Control Board Over Severe Staffing Shortage Read More »

Supreme Court Backs Himachal Pradesh’s Claim to Higher Hydropower Royalties

Leave a Comment / Live cases /

Trending Today Supreme Court Backs Himachal Pradesh’s Claim to Higher Hydropower Royalties Haryana Moves Supreme Court to Shield Aravalli Hills from Cross-Border Mining LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT AMAZON WEB SERVICES, GURUGRAM LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT ADV MOKSH JAIN, MUMBAI LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT CIPLA, MUMBAI LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT ELEVATE JOB OPPORTUNITY AT ANB LEGAL LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT NAKS LEGAL LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT JP LAW ASSOCIATES LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT IVY LAW OFFICES LLP Supreme Court Backs Himachal Pradesh’s Claim to Higher Hydropower Royalties Kashish Jahan 19 JULY 2025 The Supreme Court has ruled in favor of Himachal Pradesh, restoring 18% royalty from JSW Energy’s hydropower project. This landmark verdict secures state revenue and sets a powerful precedent for resource-sharing agreements in India. Supreme Court’s Landmark Verdict: A Victory for State Revenue Rights In a major win for Himachal Pradesh, the Supreme Court of India has ruled that the state is entitled to an 18% royalty from the Karcham–Wangtoo Hydropower Project, overriding the 12% cap previously defended by JSW Energy. The verdict reinforces the terms of a 1999 agreement and is expected to significantly boost the state’s revenue. Background: The Royalty Dispute Unfolds The core issue stemmed from a 1999 power-sharing agreement that mandated: 12% royalty for the first 12 years of operations A rise to 18% royalty thereafter However, in 2023, JSW Energy refused to implement the hike, arguing that the 12% cap should remain in place indefinitely. This led to a legal standoff that impacted the state’s fiscal health. Himachal’s Fiscal Future Looks Brighter Chief Minister Sukhvinder Singh Sukhu welcomed the verdict, calling it a “significant boost” to the hill state’s economy. With tourism and horticulture revenues fluctuating due to climate and market factors, the court’s decision brings stability. Financial Impact: ₹150 crore in immediate annual revenue gain ₹250 crore more annually if similar verdicts are passed on other projects These funds can be redirected to essential infrastructure and welfare schemes. Legal and Economic Precedent for Other States Senior advocate Kapil Sibal, who represented the Himachal government, noted that the ruling reinforces the legal sanctity of resource-sharing contracts. This sets a precedent for other Indian states seeking equitable terms from private developers utilizing local resources like rivers, forests, and mineral reserves. Implications for India’s Hydropower Sector This judgment sends a strong signal to the hydropower industry. Experts believe it will encourage: Contractual clarity in public-private partnerships Review of outdated agreements by private players Risk reassessment in large-scale infrastructure investments Citizens stand to benefit as increased state earnings could fund development in roads, education, healthcare, and rural electrification. What’s Next for Himachal Pradesh? The state is now focused on: Recovering arrears from JSW Energy Ensuring timely payments of future royalties Auditing other hydropower contracts for similar discrepancies This bold move may inspire other Himalayan states—like Uttarakhand and Sikkim—to demand fair compensation for the exploitation of their natural resources. Conclusion: Strengthening State Autonomy in Resource Management The Supreme Court’s judgment is not just a legal win but a political and financial milestone. It empowers states to enforce contractual obligations and protect their economic sovereignty in the face of corporate interests. This ruling has the potential to reshape India’s federal approach to natural resource governance. Leave a Reply Cancel Reply Logged in as Sadalaw. Edit your profile. Log out? Required fields are marked * Message* Live Cases Supreme Court Backs Himachal Pradesh’s Claim to Higher Hydropower Royalties Sadalaw • July 19, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments Haryana Moves Supreme Court to Shield Aravalli Hills from Cross-Border Mining Sadalaw • July 19, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments Kerala Government Grants Early Release to Sherin After 14 Years in Familial Murder Case Sadalaw • July 18, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments 1 2 3 … 5 Next »

Supreme Court Backs Himachal Pradesh’s Claim to Higher Hydropower Royalties Read More »

Haryana Moves Supreme Court to Shield Aravalli Hills from Cross-Border Mining

Leave a Comment / Live cases /

Trending Today Haryana Moves Supreme Court to Shield Aravalli Hills from Cross-Border Mining LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT AMAZON WEB SERVICES, GURUGRAM LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT ADV MOKSH JAIN, MUMBAI LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT CIPLA, MUMBAI LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT ELEVATE JOB OPPORTUNITY AT ANB LEGAL LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT NAKS LEGAL LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT JP LAW ASSOCIATES LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT IVY LAW OFFICES LLP LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT MAMMOET, MUMBAI Haryana Moves Supreme Court to Shield Aravalli Hills from Cross-Border Mining Kashish Jahan 19 JULY 2025 Haryana has approached the Supreme Court to halt mining within 5 km inside Rajasthan’s Aravalli range, citing ecological damage. Learn why this legal move could set a national precedent in forest conservation. A Legal Push to Save the Ancient Aravallis In a bold environmental move, the Haryana government has filed a petition in the Supreme Court of India to ban mining operations within five kilometres of the Aravalli Hills on the Rajasthan side of the border. This legal plea highlights growing concerns over rampant extraction activities damaging one of the world’s oldest mountain ranges. Why Haryana Intervened Despite state-level bans and the creation of green buffer zones, illegal and unchecked mining activities just across the Haryana-Rajasthan border persist. According to officials, mining leases granted in Rajasthan allow heavy equipment and trucks to cross the boundary easily, bypassing Haryana’s environmental safeguards. This undermines the state’s conservation efforts and accelerates ecological degradation. What Haryana Is Demanding The Haryana government is requesting the Supreme Court to establish a legally enforceable mining-free buffer zone stretching at least five kilometres inside Rajasthan territory. The aim is to protect: Water recharge zones Wildlife corridors Air and soil quality Such a buffer would act as a green belt, preventing further deforestation and mining-related damage to the fragile ecosystem. The Stakes for Rajasthan While Rajasthan‘s government has yet to officially respond, mining leaseholders in districts like Alwar are raising concerns about economic losses and job cuts. However, environmentalists argue that short-term employment cannot justify irreversible ecological loss. “The Aravallis don’t follow state lines, and neither should our conservation efforts,” one activist commented. Why the Aravalli Range Matters The Aravalli Range plays a critical environmental role in North India. It acts as a: Green barrier against desertification from the Thar Desert Air purifier for NCR cities like Gurgaon and Delhi Groundwater recharge zone Unchecked mining and deforestation here contribute to: Groundwater depletion Air pollution Soil erosion Loss of biodiversity What Happens Next? The Supreme Court’s verdict could mark a turning point in India’s environmental policy. If the court agrees with Haryana’s request, it may set a legal precedent for cross-border conservation zones—paving the way for cooperative ecological protection that transcends state boundaries. Final Thoughts As climate change intensifies, India’s fragile ecosystems need stronger legal protection. Haryana’s proactive move might spark a national conversation on sustainable development, interstate environmental cooperation, and the need to prioritize long-term ecological health over short-term economic gains. Leave a Reply Cancel Reply Logged in as Sadalaw. Edit your profile. Log out? Required fields are marked * Message* Live Cases Haryana Moves Supreme Court to Shield Aravalli Hills from Cross-Border Mining Sadalaw • July 19, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments Kerala Government Grants Early Release to Sherin After 14 Years in Familial Murder Case Sadalaw • July 18, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments Supreme Court Exempts Stem Cell Banking from Service Tax: A Landmark Healthcare Ruling Sadalaw • July 18, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments 1 2 3 … 5 Next »

Haryana Moves Supreme Court to Shield Aravalli Hills from Cross-Border Mining Read More »

Kerala Government Grants Early Release to Sherin After 14 Years in Familial Murder Case

Leave a Comment / Live cases /

Trending Today Kerala Government Grants Early Release to Sherin After 14 Years in Familial Murder Case Supreme Court Exempts Stem Cell Banking from Service Tax: A Landmark Healthcare Ruling Supreme Court Grants Bail to Rajkot Fire Officer in TRP Game Zone Tragedy LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT BAJAJ HOUSING FINANCE LEGAL INTERNSHIP OPPORTUNITY AT NC LEGAL, ADVOCATES & SOLICITORS LEGAL INTERNSHIP OPPORTUNITY AT BLACK SUIT LEGAL INTERNSHIP OPPORTUNITY AT CHAMBER OF PANKAJ RISHI KRISHNAN SINGH LEGAL INTERNSHIP OPPORTUNITY AT TRY BENCH ZERO LEGAL INTERNSHIP OPPORTUNITY AT WERIZE, BENGALURU LEGAL INTERNSHIP OPPORTUNITY AT CHAMBERS OF ASHISH MEHTA, MUMBAI Kerala Government Grants Early Release to Sherin After 14 Years in Familial Murder Case Kashish Jahan 18 JULY 2025 The Kerala government has approved the early release of Sherin, convicted in a 2009 familial murder case, after serving 14 years in prison. The remission, based on good conduct under BNSS Section 475, has sparked public debate and legal scrutiny. Background: Sherin’s Conviction in a Familial Murder In 2009, Sherin was convicted for orchestrating the murder of her father-in-law over a property dispute. Her conviction was upheld by both the Kerala High Court and the Supreme Court of India. After serving 14 years in prison, the Kerala government issued a formal remission order, allowing her early release. What Led to Her Early Release? Sherin’s release was recommended by the State Jail Advisory Board, which assessed her good conduct, discipline, and rehabilitation record while in prison. Based on these findings, the government exercised its powers under Section 475 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNSS), India’s updated criminal code, which allows remission for prisoners who meet certain criteria. Public Reactions: A Divided Response The decision has triggered a wave of public debate. Critics argue that remission should not be extended to individuals convicted of heinous crimes—especially those involving betrayal of family trust. On the other hand, proponents of criminal reformation stress the importance of offering second chances to rehabilitated individuals who have served long terms. Legal Framework: Section 475 of BNSS According to Section 475 of the BNSS, remission can be granted to prisoners who: Exhibit consistent good behavior Participate in rehabilitation programs Show potential for reintegrating into society Officials state that Sherin met these conditions, making her eligible for early release under Kerala’s remission policy. Human Rights Perspective: Emphasis on Rehabilitation Human rights advocates have underlined the need for robust post-release monitoring and rehabilitation support to ensure that the remission serves its reformative goal. They argue that release should not just be an administrative action but a part of a structured reintegration plan. Potential Legal Challenge Ahead Legal experts suggest that victims’ families or public interest litigants may challenge the government’s decision. If so, the High Court might review whether the remission aligns with the interests of justice, especially in cases involving serious or violent crimes. Conclusion Sherin’s early release after 14 years in prison reflects the evolving application of India’s remission laws under the BNSS. While it highlights the justice system’s capacity for reform and rehabilitation, it also reignites the debate on how to balance public safety, victim rights, and second chances. Whether this case sets a broader precedent or sparks judicial intervention remains to be seen. Leave a Reply Cancel Reply Logged in as Sadalaw. Edit your profile. Log out? Required fields are marked * Message* Live Cases Kerala Government Grants Early Release to Sherin After 14 Years in Familial Murder Case Sadalaw • July 18, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments Supreme Court Exempts Stem Cell Banking from Service Tax: A Landmark Healthcare Ruling Sadalaw • July 18, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments Supreme Court Grants Bail to Rajkot Fire Officer in TRP Game Zone Tragedy Sadalaw • July 18, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments 1 2 3 … 5 Next »

Kerala Government Grants Early Release to Sherin After 14 Years in Familial Murder Case Read More »

Supreme Court Exempts Stem Cell Banking from Service Tax: A Landmark Healthcare Ruling

Leave a Comment / Live cases /

Trending Today Supreme Court Exempts Stem Cell Banking from Service Tax: A Landmark Healthcare Ruling Supreme Court Grants Bail to Rajkot Fire Officer in TRP Game Zone Tragedy LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT BAJAJ HOUSING FINANCE LEGAL INTERNSHIP OPPORTUNITY AT NC LEGAL, ADVOCATES & SOLICITORS LEGAL INTERNSHIP OPPORTUNITY AT BLACK SUIT LEGAL INTERNSHIP OPPORTUNITY AT CHAMBER OF PANKAJ RISHI KRISHNAN SINGH LEGAL INTERNSHIP OPPORTUNITY AT TRY BENCH ZERO LEGAL INTERNSHIP OPPORTUNITY AT WERIZE, BENGALURU LEGAL INTERNSHIP OPPORTUNITY AT CHAMBERS OF ASHISH MEHTA, MUMBAI JOB OPPORTUNITY AT FIETTA LLP, LONDON Supreme Court Exempts Stem Cell Banking from Service Tax: A Landmark Healthcare Ruling Prabhat Kumar Biltoria 18 JULY 2025 The Supreme Court of India has ruled that stem cell banking services are exempt from service tax as part of healthcare services. This landmark judgment broadens the scope of healthcare-related tax exemptions and sets a strong precedent for advanced medical services. Background: What Are Stem Cell Banking Services? Stem cell banking involves the collection, testing, processing, preservation, and long-term storage of stem cells—often from umbilical cord blood—to be used in future medical treatments. It plays a vital role in preventive healthcare, offering hope in treating serious conditions like leukemia, lymphoma, and genetic disorders. Case Overview: Stemcyte India vs Revenue Authorities The case originated when Stemcyte India Therapeutics Pvt. Ltd. received a service tax demand exceeding ₹2 crore for services provided between July 1, 2012, and February 16, 2014. The Revenue Department argued that stem cell banking services were not classified as healthcare and thus were taxable. Supreme Court’s Verdict: Stem Cell Services Are Healthcare The Supreme Court of India rejected the Revenue’s argument and held that the services in question fall under preventive healthcare. Key points from the ruling: The exemption was granted under Entry 2 of Notification No. 25/2012-ST, which covers healthcare services offered by clinical establishments. The Court clarified that Notification No. 4/2014-ST, which later added Entry 2A to explicitly exempt cord blood banks, served as a clarification, not a restriction. Therefore, the exemption applied to Stemcyte’s services even before the 2014 clarification. No Fraud, No Suppression: Full Disclosure by Stemcyte The Court emphasized that Stemcyte India had fully disclosed all facts and had even approached tax authorities seeking guidance on the exemption. It found no evidence of fraud, intentional suppression, or tax evasion, and thus, ruled that: The extended limitation period for raising tax demands did not apply. The company must be refunded the ₹40 lakh it deposited during the investigation within four weeks. All penalties and interest charges imposed were nullified. Wider Impact: A Precedent for Advanced Medical Services This ruling is not only a victory for Stemcyte India but also a significant precedent for: Advanced medical services like stem cell storage, which support future health treatments. Recognition of such services as part of public healthcare, eligible for tax exemptions. The judgment reflects the Court’s broad interpretation of what constitutes healthcare services under Indian tax law and encourages innovation in preventive medicine. Conclusion By categorizing stem cell banking under healthcare services, the Supreme Court has reaffirmed its commitment to supporting emerging medical technologies that enhance public health. The judgment ensures that healthcare innovations remain accessible and are not burdened by unjust taxation, setting a strong example for future policy considerations. Leave a Reply Cancel Reply Logged in as Sadalaw. Edit your profile. Log out? Required fields are marked * Message* Live Cases Supreme Court Exempts Stem Cell Banking from Service Tax: A Landmark Healthcare Ruling Sadalaw • July 18, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments Supreme Court Grants Bail to Rajkot Fire Officer in TRP Game Zone Tragedy Sadalaw • July 18, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments Gurugram Tragedy: Father Arrested for Murder of Daughter Radhika Yadav, Former Tennis Star Sadalaw • July 15, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments 1 2 3 … 5 Next »

Supreme Court Exempts Stem Cell Banking from Service Tax: A Landmark Healthcare Ruling Read More »

Supreme Court Grants Bail to Rajkot Fire Officer in TRP Game Zone Tragedy

Leave a Comment / Live cases /

Trending Today Supreme Court Grants Bail to Rajkot Fire Officer in TRP Game Zone Tragedy LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT BAJAJ HOUSING FINANCE LEGAL INTERNSHIP OPPORTUNITY AT NC LEGAL, ADVOCATES & SOLICITORS LEGAL INTERNSHIP OPPORTUNITY AT BLACK SUIT LEGAL INTERNSHIP OPPORTUNITY AT CHAMBER OF PANKAJ RISHI KRISHNAN SINGH LEGAL INTERNSHIP OPPORTUNITY AT TRY BENCH ZERO LEGAL INTERNSHIP OPPORTUNITY AT WERIZE, BENGALURU LEGAL INTERNSHIP OPPORTUNITY AT CHAMBERS OF ASHISH MEHTA, MUMBAI JOB OPPORTUNITY AT FIETTA LLP, LONDON LEGAL JOB OPPORTUNITY AT GBA LAW OFFICES Supreme Court Grants Bail to Rajkot Fire Officer in TRP Game Zone Tragedy Prabhat Kumar Biltoria 18 JULY 2025 The Supreme Court has granted bail to Rajkot Chief Fire Officer Ileshkumār Kher in the 2024 TRP Game Zone fire tragedy that claimed 27 lives. Learn how the ruling highlights the importance of individual responsibility and liberty in negligence cases. Background: TRP Game Zone Fire Tragedy in Gujarat On May 25, 2024, a devastating fire broke out at the TRP Game Zone in Rajkot, Gujarat, leading to the tragic deaths of 27 individuals, including several children. The incident exposed massive fire safety violations, poor infrastructure, and non-compliance with licensing regulations, sparking national outrage and administrative scrutiny. Who is Ileshkumar Valabhai Kher? Ileshkumar Valabhai Kher served as the Chief Fire Officer of Rajkot District at the time of the incident. He was among several government and civic officials arrested for alleged negligence and failure to enforce proper safety measures. Supreme Court Overturns Gujarat High Court Decision A Supreme Court of India bench comprising Justices Manoj Misra and Ujjal Bhuyan granted Kher bail, reversing the earlier denial by the Gujarat High Court. The Court emphasized that: Kher’s role in the fire was supervisory and “extremely remote.” He had already been in judicial custody for over a year. The trial was unlikely to begin soon due to the presence of 365 named witnesses. Bail Supported by Legal Principles of Liberty The apex court reiterated that bail jurisprudence prioritizes individual liberty, especially when the accused is not directly responsible for the tragic event. The Court stated that if the allegations were proven, they would largely indicate negligence rather than criminal homicide. This legal stance shifts the focus from extended pre-trial detention to the presumption of innocence and the need to differentiate between direct and indirect accountability. Negligence, Licensing, and Accountability Previously, the Gujarat High Court had denied bail to Kher, along with several town planning officers and TRP Game Zone co-owners, while granting bail to three municipal officials. A sessions court also denied discharge petitions of seven other accused due to prima facie evidence of gross negligence and violation of fire and construction norms. The tragedy brought attention to: Lack of Fire NOC (No Objection Certificate) Improper building approvals Administrative oversight failures What This Means for Future Cases The Supreme Court’s verdict could set a precedent for other disaster-related negligence cases. It reinforces the idea that while systemic flaws must be addressed, criminal responsibility should be based on direct involvement rather than merely holding a supervisory position. Conclusion The TRP Game Zone fire remains a painful reminder of the cost of regulatory failure and administrative neglect. The bail granted to Ileshkumar Kher underscores the importance of fair legal process, especially when the accused’s role is limited or indirect. As the judicial system continues to hold individuals accountable, it must also push for structural reforms to prevent such tragedies in the future. Leave a Reply Cancel Reply Logged in as Sadalaw. Edit your profile. Log out? Required fields are marked * Message* Live Cases Supreme Court Grants Bail to Rajkot Fire Officer in TRP Game Zone Tragedy Sadalaw • July 18, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments Gurugram Tragedy: Father Arrested for Murder of Daughter Radhika Yadav, Former Tennis Star Sadalaw • July 15, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments Illegal Sand Mining Surges in Rajasthan: Crackdown Intensifies Amid Monsoon Ban Sadalaw • July 14, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments 1 2 3 … 5 Next »

Supreme Court Grants Bail to Rajkot Fire Officer in TRP Game Zone Tragedy Read More »

Get A Quote
Get A Quote