Supreme Court Declines Sentence in POCSO Case as Victim Now Married to Convict and Opposes Punishment
Trending Today YouTuber Jyoti Malhotra Arrested for Espionage: No Regrets Over Leaking Info to Pakistan ISI Supreme Court Halts Discharge of Woman IAF Officer Involved in Operations Sindoor and Balakot Amid PC Denial Dispute Supreme Court Quashes Gangster Act FIR Against SHUATS VC, Cites Abuse of Legal Process Supreme Court Slams Indian Navy for Denying Permanent Commission to Female JAG Officer Supreme Court Declines Sentence in POCSO Case as Victim Now Married to Convict and Opposes Punishment Supreme Court Verdict on Dr. Jaya Thakur v. Union of India: Challenge to EC Appointment Process & Section 7(1) of 2023 Act Supreme Court Verdict on Article 370: Constitutionality of Jammu & Kashmir Reorganization Upheld Delhi High Court Dismisses Section 377 Case, Cites Lack of Marital Rape Recognition Under Indian Law Bombay High Court Quashes Non-Bailable Warrant Against Actor Arjun Rampal in Tax Evasion Case Trump’s India-Pakistan Ceasefire Claim Mocked by Ex-NSA John Bolton Supreme Court Declines Sentence in POCSO Case as Victim Now Married to Convict and Opposes Punishment PRABAHAT KUMAR BILTORIA 24 May 2025 The Supreme Court of India declined to sentence a POCSO convict, citing the victim’s opposition to punishment and her current marital relationship with the accused. Learn about the landmark ruling under Article 142 and its implications on the legal system. Landmark Supreme Court Ruling Under Article 142 On Friday, May 23, the Supreme Court of India ruled against sentencing a man convicted under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (POCSO Act). The bench, invoking its authority under Article 142 of the Constitution, noted that the victim—now an adult and married to the convict—did not view the incident as a crime. Victim Faced More Harm from Legal and Social Fallout The Court emphasized that although the act was legally an offense, the victim did not perceive it as such. According to the official report, the victim endured greater trauma from the legal and societal consequences rather than the act itself. Her struggle involved navigating police procedures, enduring court trials, and fighting to protect her husband from conviction. Emotional Bond and Current Family Life Influenced Decision The accused married the victim following the incident, and they now live together with their child. The bench, comprising Justices Abhay Oka and Ujjal Bhuyan, recognized the deep emotional connection the victim had developed with the convict. She had become, as noted, “very possessive about her small family.” Court Highlights Systemic Failures in Justice Delivery This judgment also spotlighted the failures of the legal system, society, and the victim’s own family. The Court remarked that “her own family abandoned her, the legal system failed her, and society judged her,” thereby denying her the opportunity to make informed decisions earlier. Instructions to State and Ministry of Women and Child Development Alongside the ruling, the Court issued preliminary instructions to the State Government and sent a notice to the Ministry of Women and Child Development. These directives aim to address the recommendations provided by the Amicus Curiae, with more detailed orders to follow upon release of the final judgment. Conclusion: A Controversial Yet Eye-Opening Judicial Precedent The Supreme Court’s decision to forgo sentencing in this POCSO Act case has ignited important conversations around justice, victim agency, and the limitations of the current legal framework. By exercising its powers under Article 142, the Court prioritized context, emotional well-being, and the wishes of the now-adult victim over rigid legal formalism. This ruling not only exposes the challenges victims face in the aftermath of such cases but also calls for urgent reform and sensitivity within the judicial system. As the nation reflects on this precedent, it remains critical to balance the rule of law with compassion, autonomy, and societal accountability. Leave a Reply Cancel Reply Logged in as Sadalaw Publications. Edit your profile. Log out? Required fields are marked * Message* Live Cases YouTuber Jyoti Malhotra Arrested for Espionage: No Regrets Over Leaking Info to Pakistan ISI YouTuber Jyoti Malhotra Arrested for Espionage: No Regrets Over Leaking Info to Pakistan ISI Sada Law • May 24, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments Supreme Court Halts Discharge of Woman IAF Officer Involved in Operations Sindoor and Balakot Amid PC Denial Dispute Supreme Court Halts Discharge of Woman IAF Officer Involved in Operations Sindoor and Balakot Amid PC Denial Dispute Sada Law • May 24, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments Supreme Court Quashes Gangster Act FIR Against SHUATS VC, Cites Abuse of Legal Process Supreme Court Quashes Gangster Act FIR Against SHUATS VC, Cites Abuse of Legal Process Sada Law • May 24, 2025 • Live cases • No Comments 1 2 3 … 5 Next »